Eat and drink
What each place is, so you can pick the right one.
Tybee has maybe two dozen places worth your time and they are not interchangeable. This is a description of what each one is and when it works — not a ranking, and not a list of everything on the island.
Owner's note
Hours, menus and ownership on a barrier island change fast, and several of these close or shorten their week in the off season. Call ahead in January. If we have steered you wrong, tell us.
On the water
The Crab Shack
The island's best-known restaurant, dockside on Chimney Creek, built around the Lowcountry boil. It is loud, outdoors, on the water, and unapologetically a tourist institution — which does not make it bad, it makes it a specific thing. Go for the setting and the boil, with a group, early.
Not a quiet dinner. Nobody has ever had a quiet dinner here.
The Deck Beach Bar + Kitchen
Built into the dunes with direct beach access, which on Tybee is rare enough to be the whole pitch. Seafood and cocktails with the Atlantic in front of you. This is the sunset-drink answer.
Pier 16 Seafood
Rooftop dining near the pier with ocean views. The reason to come is the elevation — on an island this flat, a second storey is a view.
Near North Beach and the lighthouse
North Beach Bar & Grill
Caribbean-leaning cooking with a stated focus on sustainable, fresh seafood; the fish tacos are what it is known for. Pairs naturally with a lighthouse morning and a low-tide walk on the north end.
Huc-A-Poos
Pizza, beer, and enormous nachos in a shopping-district building that does not look like much from outside. A local fixture more than a destination.
Order fewer nachos than you think. This is advice, not a dare.
Tybean Art & Coffee Bar
Coffee and fresh scones in the Tybee Oaks shopping district. The morning stop before a north-end walk.
Mid-island, walkable from the 1100 block
Fannie's on the Beach
Twenty-six years in, casual, beach-facing, known for gourmet pizza and mahi tacos, with a walk-up window that solves the problem of being sandy and hungry at the same time.
Sundae Cafe
Family-owned, seafood and Southern plates, and the closest thing on the island to a proper sit-down dinner. This is the one to book if you need one nice evening out of the week.
Sting Ray's Seafood
Relaxed, local-leaning, with live music on a two-storey outdoor patio. Good when you want the evening to be long and unplanned.
Sugar Shack
Thirty-plus years of hand-dipped ice cream, including banana pudding and pralines and cream. The correct end to a beach day and a reliable bribe.